Dear Jett, we are really sorry for the inconvenience. The item you lost was logged on FindMyLost for Trenitalia on the same date it was found (the 11th of September), you searched and requested it 6 days later (on the 17th) but it was assigned to you on the same day. Thanks to our software you were able to get your item assigned to you on the same day you requested it!
However, differently from the partnerships we have with other companies, we are not in charge of shipping on the Trenitalia account: shipping, in fact, is provided by another company so you should contact them. We are not the company you have been contacting by phone so you are reviewing the wrong company.
We understand that the final step of the process could be misleading, in fact we usually offer the integrated shipping. We are working to implement shipping also on the Trenitalia account (https://trenitalia.findmylost.it) but, unfortunately, it does not depend on us. If you ever have the possibility to use our service with another partner in the future, you will be able to experience a seamless experience with integrated shipping. Thank you for your feedback!