10 weeks, 4 companies and an interrogation before settlement
I took out an insurance policy with 'Swinton'. When my motorbike was stolen I was referred to KGM who, as underwriters, would reportedly handle my claim from that point onwards. At some point a company called 'Auto Accident Claims Limited' became involved along with another company called 'Robertsonandco'.
Now, I would like to think that when a vehicle is stolen for which you have insurance for that the insurance company would pay out in a timely fashion. This was most certainly not the case. My bike was stolen on 7th April 2025.
The insurance company, from the very first day, did make it clear that they weren't able to offer any timeframes for when the matter would be resolved and that it would take as long as it would take. (Is this even allowed?)
Obviously I filed a police report but this wasn't evidence enough for the insurance company who decided then to employ a private investigator to attend my home to interview me for an hour as to the circumstances that led to the theft. (Every single detail provided to the investigator had already been provided to the underwriters and no new information was given to the investigator). The appointment for this interrogation didn't take place until 23rd April 2025.
Subsequent to this appointment I chased the insurance company/underwriters on approximately 6 or 7 occasions to try to get an update as to when there were going to pay out. On each occasion I was told that it was with the private investigators still or that the report had been received and that one department or another was 'processing' the report. On each occasion I was told they couldn't tell me how long it would be before the next step would be reached and that I was welcome to chase again at a later date.
Finally on 23rd May 2025 I received a letter, this time from AAC Ltd saying that everything was in order and they offered me a settlement price which, as I discovered, was way below market value. After contesting this and providing evidence of the actual market value and then hearing nothing again for days and days, I eventually received another email on 30th May 2025 asking me to send in my service history as they might then be able to increase the offer. I did so immediately and (again after many chasing phone calls) I eventually received an increased settlement offer on 13th June. (The increased offer was around 18% higher, or £1,200, more than the initial offer).
I accepted this immediately and then phoned them on 9th June to see if they had received my service history and to see when I could expect the payment. The operator spoke to someone in the total loss team whilst I was on the phone and came back and said that payment would be made that same day.
When this didn't materialise I called them again on 11th June to be told that the total loss team had my file in their hands right there and then and would receive payment that day.
Again, this never happened. I contacted them on 13th June to complain and was told that I would definitely receive payment on 16th June. This did happen!
As a result of me raising a complaint on the 13th June I then received an email from the complaints department on 16th June which went on to say that they felt that the time between the report of theft and the initial offer of a settlement (Just under 7 weeks) was reasonable. They then followed this with, and I quote, "It is clear that whilst reviewing your claim opportunities have been missed to progress your claim more efficiently than it did and update you about the claim and what was happening at each stage". They concluded with the following, "Based on our investigation, the outcome is that your complaint is upheld....If you wish to do so, you have the right to refer your complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service"
That was it...my complaint was upheld but no mention as to any form of financial recompense to help me recoup some of the huge losses I have incurred whilst waiting for 10 weeks for my claim to be settled and for me to receive the settlement.
We don't have a lot of choice as bikers as to which insurance companies we use and therefore underwriters but I will certainly be doing everything in my power to make sure that Swinton, KGM and AAC do not feature again in any product I use.
And of course, I will now be contacting the Financial Ombudsman Service.
16 June 2025
Unprompted review