mtgcardsmith.com Reviews 49

What appears like a fantastic custom MTG card builder is actually a complete mess of dysfunction.

This website barely works, and it requires extreme patience. The fact the owner of the site has a subscription model is genuinely hilarious. Siphoning money from people who don't know any better. Shame on whoever runs it.

SCAM ALERT! This site has become a scam. New site owners who refuse to cancel subscription once you have signed up. There is no way to cancel your subscription on the site and the site staff (via contact us) forms will ignore your requests to cancel your subscription. The only option you have is to go through your bank directly.

Took days after completing my order to mail it, then usps loses it and I’m denied a refund. Do not order from here.

The proxies are really high quality, with cool cardback choices. The turnaround time is quite good. The ordering process is clear and easy to follow. Good stuff.

I've ordered several custom proxies through them. They're really great. They come fast with good quality to the prints. One was an anniversary present for my fiance and he loved it, gets tons of compliments all the time.

Only reason it's not getting a five is because the Foil upgrade is just kinda meh. It doesn't change the card much and I don't think it's really worth it

Love this site. Easy to use, I’m a newcomer and I was able to create some awesome cards from my favorite universe KOTOR. I loved the easy to use creator mode which has filters for all different types of mtg cards and even inspired the creation of other cards. I really loved the section for choosing custom card backs and chose the spongebob ones!! :D

Quick, painless, fun, gives you a sense of creativity when you make a proxy. Love this and highly recommend anybody in the beginning stages of proxying cards, start here!

It was great, easy to use, high quality, and fast delivery.

Great website and easy to make cards! We just made each other as Commanders and we are going to build decks around the abilities we came up with!

I’ve ordered multiple printings from MTGCardsmith, and every time, the quality has been outstanding! The website is easy to use, making the process of creating and ordering custom cards smooth and enjoyable. Shipping is always fast, and the cards arrive in excellent condition.

The foil prints are particularly impressive—no peeling, flaking, or dull spots—just crisp, vibrant artwork that really stands out. The color accuracy and overall print quality are spot on, making the cards look and feel professional.

Whenever I play with my custom cards, my opponents always ask where I got them printed, and I never hesitate to recommend MTGCardsmith.com. If you’re looking for high-quality custom MTG cards, this is the place to go!

Amazing proxies. Highly recommend utilizing their services when cards are hard to acquire elsewhere! Best proxy site around!

2nd time ordering from them, thankfully the ordering process is easy, and they offer bulk discounts which was great. The card maker works pretty well too to customize items.

Wonderful service! I’ve custom made and ordered cards from them twice so far, and I’ve been extremely impressed with the ease of design and high quality of the prints! Currently making my own custom deck and will continue to use this service all the way through! Highly recommend!!

The card creator is very easy and enjoyable to use. The quality of the cards is good, too. I didn't expect the cards to be a 1/1 copy of a traditional Magic card, and they aren't, but they are close enough. I'm very satisfied with the product the company puts out.

This is my second order through cardsmith and I love the quality. I had a blast designing the cards for my Hare Apparently deck the first time. This time I ordered a Valentine's card for the hubby with our wedding photo on it. For next time, I would love to see old border options from original magic cards. I attempted to use the token maker, but it shouldn't fit all the letters for Astartes Warrior. Also, scaling was awkward so I gave up. I would love to see the token generator have the same level as the regular card one. But otherwise, awesome job guys and can't wait to use it again!

I ordered my cards at the same time that I ordered some proxies and these got here about 4 days earlier. When one of the cards seemed misprinted, I contacted them and they gave me a coupon for five free cards on a future order, even though it turned out that the error was my own fault during the design process. My experience was so enjoyable I've considered using this company to get proxies even though that's not specifically what they do.

Ive bought cards from them a couple times now and havent been disappointed. Its really easy to make a card and its even easier to buy them and track them. Im waiting on another batch of cards for myself as we speak. lol

The platform to create and personalize the cards is the best I personally experienced. I couldn't find nothing similar and so detailed. The final look is extremely good, and if you take your time and personalize them pretty well putting a fantasy picture they truly look like original MTG cards. I don't know from PC if is the same cause I only used from Phone, but all worked well. Unfortunately being my first time using it I wasn't experienced and had to make another order for the same cards cause the first I made had lots of mistakes. But that was on me. They didn't do anything wrong. The only flaw, if I can call it so, is that once you uploaded your image, if you want to re-upload the pic, even if you almost finished creating the card with all the details, you have to start from the beginning, so instead of only making you change the image it restart from 0, ao you have to make everything again. Everything else I think is well made! Love the foil choice!

Wow! My first order from mtgcardsmith.com was shipped super-fast. The quality of card stock and printing is almost perfect. After this second order the Wolfriders will live again in my new commander deck!

There's nothing to complain about or not like about this website. I made cards... ordered cards... it was easy, straight to the point, . Cards came in the mail and that's it... 5 stars seems reasonable.