The Old School Game Vault Reviews 179

Sold my old video games on this website. The process was easy to use, and the staff was friendly and responsive to my questions.

I received payment very quickly after being notified that my package had arrived at their location.

I’d recommend The Old School Game Vault to anyone looking to sell their old video games or gaming consoles!!

Good communication throughout the process. No issues.

All around great experience. Quick response, process straight forward and simple. Payment received in a timely manner for the exact amount quoted. I wasn't sure what to expect but I will use again if I have games to sell

I have sold a number of items to The Old School Game Vault and they have never disappointed me. My recent experience with the Old School Game Vault in January 2026 was also a success. This company is honest, fair and trustworthy. After receiving the items, payment is within a few days. The company also communicates very well and keeps the seller informed about every step. I highly recommend selling your old games and systems to the Old School Game Vault (A+ rating from me).

Highly recommended! Great service and communication, transaction was exactly as advertised. Will be using again, thanks so much

Brandon has always been easy to work with on getting games sold and sends email updates on status of sales.

Would do business with Old School Game Vault again!

Brandon was a pleasure to do business with. I've sold games twice to him and the process went smoothly and as expected.

Very communicative and paid in a timely manner after receiving my items.

Great experience from start to finish. I had excellent communication with the buyer from asking questions about selling, to frequent and informative updates along the way. I recieved a direct deposit for the amount quoted to me in record time. I highly recommend this site for selling of retro games!

Brandon was very prompt with reviewing and was very fair with estimate! I’m so happy I found his site!

It was great doing business with Brandon! I had a Nintendo Switch and an assortment of older Nintendo games that I needed to sell and he had the best prices, a super easy process, and made the payment in a very timely manner. I absolutely recommend doing business with The Old School Game Vault!

I have used The Old School Game Vault twice now and have had a great experience both times. The process is very easy and quick. They send you a USPS label to ship your items. Payment is very quick. I will definitely use again in the future!

I sent the game vault about 111 games, which came out to just around $3,000 according to the quote I got on their website. The process was quick and efficient.

They sent me two pre-paid UPS shipping labels, then quickly followed up the same day the packages were delivered with a nice email letting me know the packages arrived safely.

They let me know that they would need a few days to process the order, and test the contents of each package. After a couple of days they let me know, everything checked out and worked and issued instant payment to my bank account through Zelle. The final amount of our transaction was $3,003.87.

I can’t recommend this company enough, how many places online can you send $3,000 dollars’ worth of merchandise and actually get paid for it?

I sent in a PS2, a Wii U, and 3 GameCube controllers earlier this month. They did receive my shipment, I got what they quoted. I wanted a check since I don't use PayPal or Zelle. The expected delivery date was 2/24 but I don't know if that's when it's sent out or when I can find it in the mail. I asked about it today only to get a rude response.

Well, screw you! I just asked an innocent question to clear up confusion and this is how you reply?

Edit 2/28: It's now 4 business days since they supposedly sent the business check and I still haven't received it. I can consider it lost in the mail at this point. And the owner says it's my fault for choosing an outdated payment method. Um, not everyone can use PayPal or Zelle, moron. Or did you forget that?

At this point, I don't even care anymore. If it does arrive, great. If not, whatever. Those old game consoles were taking up space in my room anyway. At least you'll find them a good home, I'll give you that.

Easy process. Wish I'd sold these games awhile ago, thank you!

Brandon made things super easy to sell my old NES set and games. Process was quick, easy and fair. Great communication throughout the process. Will be selling to him again.

Very professional and positive experience. I highly recommend.

The Old School Game Vault is the best!!

Brandon was a pleasure to do business with, always kept in touch by email to update the progress of my order!

Let me know beforehand any deductions that would take place from his original quote. So you know exactly what you are getting, depending on the condition of the games you send.

I absolutely would recommend The Old School Game Vault to anyone & will be to family & friends

Fast, Easy Process, with great communication & prompt payment!

Thanks Brandon

It was easy to sell my son's video games and I got a great price. Very satisfied with the whole process!

The website was easy to use and provided immediate pricing. After the order submission, Brandon's clarity of directions, communications, and documentation were all excellent.