Goldbelly Reviews 

Very expensive but it would have been all good if delivery was made on the date requested. It was a 50th wedding anniversary. There's also artisan ice cream that was ordered in a separate order and that too wasnt delivered as requested. Im done with this company. For these prices I should be getting top tier customer service and that is not what happened with 2 orders this week.

APRIL 24, 2026 - After 98 orders, I. AM. FRUSTRATED. Everytime you ask me to fill out the survey that says would I recommend Goldbelly to anybody, I always put the lowest score, and the reason is UPS Shipping. This, as my sister waited yesterday (Thursday, April 23) for a baked item that was ordered April 16, shipped Monday, April 20 from Duchess Cookies by UPS, meanwhile SAME EXACT item, shipped Monday delivered Thursday literally two blocks away to my niece. I called before 6pm, and your associate said, no, it should still make it tonight by 10. Really? It looks like UPS has it sitting in Jacksonville. Friday afternoon now and still NADA. 50/50 is NOT good enough. If anyone is thinking of sending Goldbelly as a gift, know that the reliability of the date you have chosen for delivery is not solid if they use UPS. I have used Goldbelly b/c of the AMAZING variety of quality, sometimes unique, shipped foods around the country and including Hawaii. I will not ever dump Goldbelly, b/c they are not the ones choosing UPS, it is the vendors.
Vendors: If you use UPS that comes through Florida, count me out.
Goldbelly Customer Service: YOU ARE SOLID, and if you ever need a tester for a potential vendor, I am your person.

I received the wrong order, and when I contacted customer service, I was told they could not send the correct item. Instead, they offered a $30 credit—which isn’t very useful given that most items on the site cost significantly more.

I’ve had these pizzas in the past (sent as gifts), and they were excellent. Unfortunately, the pizza we received this time was disappointing and not worth the price.

Between the incorrect order, lack of resolution, and decline in quality, this was a frustrating experience. I won’t be using the credit or ordering again, and I would not recommend purchasing from this company.

My order no. 28308868 was placed on 4/8/2026 and due for delivery today, 4/10/2026. I ordered 2 lbs. of the chocolate Matzo Crack - ready to eat out of the box from The Borscht Belt Delicatessen and paid $64.95. While my order was delivered on time, I received the wrong item. Rather I was sent potato latkes and about 10 jars of unmarked containers filled with liquid and/or powder. No instructions included. The chocolate matzo crack was intended for a party this weekend. I do not cook and threw out what I received. Goldbelly has a useless bot. I did receive a response from "Maureen" and sent her several pictures of what I received. It is apparent I was sent the wrong item. It's not as though my order consisted of 10 items; rather just one item. As someone that has placed multiple orders from Goldbelly over the past three years, the way to make things right is to send me what I ordered overnight at no additional charge. Not surprisingly I have not received a response from "Maureen" despite sending her photos of what I received. Service has taken a deep nosedive. Very disappointed.

I ORDERED A WEEK BEFORE I NEEDED THE CAKE YET THEY HAD NOT SHIPPED IT AT 5 P.M. THE DAY BEFORE THEN WHEN I REACHED SOMEONE SAID BASICALLY OPPS WE WILL UPGRADE YOUR SHIPPING TO OVERNIGHT.. WHAT THE H3LL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT YOU FAILED BIG TIME NOW THEY ARE SAYING THE CAKE THAT IS SUPPOSED TO BE DELIVERED TODAY WAS HELD UP CAUSE OF WEATHER AND IT WILL BE SPOILED WHEN DELIVERED MONDAY MIND YOU IT IS FRIDAY NOW AND THEY WILL NOT REFUND ME!!!! WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT YOU FAILED TO SHIP IT SO IT WOULD BE HERE ON 9TH OR 10TH A.M. AS ORDERED AND YET YOU WILL NOT REFUND..... THEY SAID NO
NOW WE ARE GOING TO BBB

I’ve used Goldbelly a few times and had good experiences, which is why this was so disappointing. I ordered a cheesesteak kit as a special pre-Easter meal, and the meat quality was unacceptable. It had a strong off/rancid odor while cooking and contained bone and excessive gristle throughout. It was not thin-sliced steak as advertised and was completely inedible. We had to throw it away and order DoorDash to replace dinner that same night.

I contacted Goldbelly immediately. They initially offered a $25 credit on a $120 order, which I declined. I was then told my case would be escalated and that I would hear back within 24 hours. That never happened.

It has now been 5 days with no response despite multiple follow-ups on my end. At this point, the lack of communication is as concerning as the original issue.

This was not a matter of preference, the product was not usable. What’s most disappointing is that once a real issue arose, Goldbelly stopped responding rather than resolving it.

Based on this experience, I would be very cautious ordering perishable items through Goldbelly.

I received a gift from a friend. It was a cheesecake. When it arrived and we opened it, the cake had melted into a blob. The package itself had had a flimsy plastic bag that we assume once had ice of some kind in it. The delivery had taken 5 days via UPS standard shipping. I let my friend know and she contacted Goldbelly, who told her she would have to buy another if she wanted to but would have to wait 10 days for her refund. Very poor customer service. This is to let people know that Goldbelly will not help you make a situation right if something goes wrong. This stuff is not cheap. TTo hold someone's money for 10 days following a defective delivery is the sign of a bad business.I know Goldbelly has expanded quite a bit, but perhaps people need to know that they just are not what they used to be.

I ordered Crumbs Bakeshop Easter Cupcakes they arrived on time. When I started eating these Easter cupcakes some weren't fresh. WORST cupcakes I've had.

I got the Passover dinner from The Borscht Belt and it was so salty 2/3rds of it was inedible. I spent $150 on it and they offered a 25$ credit to their site. In the past, orders have been fine but now they won’t respond to me even after I offered to send pictures as they request in their website. Ruined Passover dinner for us this year.

Edit: We have come to a settlement. The Borscht Belt never replied to either myself or Goldbelly, but Goldbelly made it right with me. I appreciate that and I will work with Goldbelly in the future, but never order from a store with a percentage less than 90%.

I ordered an expensive strawberry several layer cake. It was meh. If I’d been blindfolded, I couldn’t have told u the prevailing flavor other than a taste of butter. I paid $100 for this? Don’t bother. At least it was on time.

They are late every single time I order. Always miss the birthday. Every. Single. Time.

I was excited when one of our clients sent a gift card, after ordering I was terribly displeased and could not believe they were getting away with what they do on a daily basis. I received four pizzas for $105 order and they were nothing more than a frozen pizza from Aldi‘s that I should’ve paid six dollars for. They should be ashamed of their self for ripping people off like this. I own a food service business and I could not live with myself if I did this to clients every day.
I did take pictures that tell the whole story but do not know how to post on here….

Awful. The wrong items were sent and they argued with me about the problem instead of fixing it. It was clearly wrong as well. I ordered a red pie (cheeseless pizza) and received a white pizza. Basic colors are clearly difficult for Goldbelly

Ordered Chris Oh's Korean meal kit for 2-4, really only good for 2. Paid an additional $34for 2lb Flanken cut ribs, what I received were basically scrap cuts, I've bought flanken cut ribs from a local farm butcher & these were not. Rice included was gummy, best part was the kimchi. This site is extremely over priced for the quality, 2nd & last order (first order was screwed by UPS - 6 day deliver for a 2nd day shipment) did get a credit - no refunds for any cause - received a reply form Goldbelly after 30days & what reads like a generic "cookbook" reply

I was excited to be gifted a Goldbelly gift card -- but what I thought would be a fun indulgence turned out to be quite a chore. First of all, figuring out what I could afford with my gift card was a challenge since shipping costs aren't listed up front - you don't see them until check-out. I initially added 2 items to my cart that used almost the whole gift card, only to be hit with an eyewatering $100 shipping fee. Trying to cobble together an order when shipping per item varied from $0-$50 was a major chore. I finally landed on a fancy cake for valentine's day ("guaranteed" to arrive before vday), and some cookies to use up the gift card - ended up having to pay $30 out of pocket to cover shipping, but se la vie. Fast forward to 2the day the cake was scheduled to arrive, 2 days before vday. It doesn't arrive and so i check the order status online and see that it had been updated that morning delaying delivery by nearly two weeks. There was no communication from Goldbelly or the bakery letting me know about the delay, and by the time it was late and i checked the status it was too late to even order something from a local bakery for vday. Splurging $100 on a dessert + $30 to ship it for a special occasion only to have it delayed 2 weeks with no communication was really a 0/10 experience, would not recommend to anybody.

I ordered something from a restaurant that’s in the same city that it was shipped from. I mean shipped too pay the highest fee that they charge. This company still shipped UPS using the slowest process to ship it. The product is a food product. It’s been riding in the back of this hot ups truck all day what does that say about a company that would do that if you’re ordering something from another state and it’s a food product what the yuck
I will never use the service again

I ordered a peach cobble from them on Jant6th and it was not properly packaged to keep froze and spoiled and thawed out in transit with leakage throughout the shipping container upon delivery by FEDEX ..I would not recommend this company for perishable items shipped out…
Dr Mitch

I have been a customer for five years and never had a bad experience. To say the least. Every delivery delighted recipients, cakes for many events to my beloveds, and for me, cardamom rolls and bread from the best bakeries in the country. Even when after years of perfect experiences, there was a delay in a Valentine's Day cake, not only did they fully reimburse me, the following evening, they also gave me full credit.

Ordered king cakes for multiple (3) office locations with the delivery set for Fat Tuesday. One cake was delivered midday to one office, while another cake was delivered an hour before that location closed for the day, and certainly after the Mardi Gras festivities at that location. Third cake delivered to an office AFTER THE OFFICE CLOSED FOR THE DAY. BUYER BEWARE: If you need a time-sensitive delivery, DO NOT USE Goldbelly as their "trusted delivery partner" UPS CANNOT be TRUSTED to deliver timely.

This was a gift. The order did not arrive when scheduled. The customer care team was not helpful. I do not recommend using this vendor for gifts. I asked the giver to request a refund.