Great American Coin Company Reviews 

I bought a silver lot for $78 and they sent two silver quarters and a silver dime. Worth very little all 1964. Never buy from again.

I placed and order today 12/29/2025 for around $600 and they canceled and refunded my money after 14 minutes. I won’t ever attempt to purchase from them again

I purchased a bag of 1000 Indian Head Cents from this company and looked them over when they arrived. I am pleased with the purchase.
Yes, I may buy from them again.

Every day I get a different excuse as to why my order still hasn't shipped. Awful customer service experience. I would highly recommend going to look at other more professional companies.

Amazing how they can double charge you and have you rate them a 5 stars too! Just an example 1g gold for $260 perth mint ??? Where in other sites(more famous and bigger companies) wallmart, Apmex.com,Govmint.com everything provided as expected and acceptable price, gold is $2900 per T-ounce and you sell a plain 1oz gold for near4.5-5k SMH, people are free to do as they wish but would you really want to pay %50-100% more than any other big Gold and precious metals? 2025 1oz lady fortuna is around $3000-$3050 (2/25/2025) very similar price for Perth mint etc but at their website they literally charge over $4500 for the same 1oz gold, even if they provide better service.. I mean what service do you get for the extra 1500 ? Yes they charge at least 50% more! Thats gold, bank notes etc 100 Trillion dollars Zimbabwe is 100-150 max same websites I mentioned earlier selling it from $150ish why $250 here? Silver eagle 1oz $51 starting??? It’s barely $38-40 why pay so much more? I suggest you do more research and know the price of your item so you won’t get ripped off! For example Costco, wallmart, APMEX.com GOVMINT.com and more( are all known and doing business over decades, i can buy 50 Grams Gold Bar with +$4500… but Great American coins company asking $4500 for regular 30 grams gold bar! Also pay attention to the writing, always type the web address not click or open from your email because worse can happen and they act instead of those company, value your assets

Never received order. I saw that they have positive reviews on here so I assumed it was legit. I looked closer at the reviews and 95% of them are from accounts that have only reviewed this company and very generic reviews. BE CAREFUL!

I have dealt with this company three times buying Vietnamese dong, Iraqi and dinar, and Zimbabwe Zim. They have reasonable prices great customer service. Very easy to order and I have even as of recent sent them probably at least 10 more customers. So I would recommend this company as a five-star company anytime

Everything I expected and super fast delivery! Thank you!!

Please dont buy from this company....waited 3 months for a parcel I paid Express delivery for... no response to any emails ... just ignored... AVOID AVOID AVOID

This is scam for me I had ordered my coins about 2 months ago haven't got them yet. That's really bad, people please be careful your can lose you money here.

sent. me the. completely WRONG coin did not Even get the year right ! hopefully they. will fix it. with out it. being a big hassle but. I. have. my. doubts will update this. post. if. and when. the. company does the right. thing. by. its. customer

Very satisfied with high-class customer service, answered all my questions quickly and clearly! Thank you for what you are, prosperity and all the best of your company!

They are excellent. Excellent pricing. Expedient shipping. Superb email communications.

Excelent!!!

The service was excellent! Fast shipment and the exact match of what was pictured on the web site. I will be a repeat customer.

Professional. Excellent service. Great products. On time deliveries!

Purchasing was easy, checkout simple, and I received my purchase quickly. Everything arrived in perfect condition.

Ordered coins ten days ago and still don’t have them or a tracking number.
Come on guys, you can do better than that.

When I order from Great American coin, I always get prompt and immediate response. I speak with him over the phone quite frequently and they are always helpful.

I love everything you guys do, except it takes you too long to ship.