Pie Insurance Reviews 

If you are an agent or broker, be away from this company. They pay the commission ONLY about 45% from what insured pays. (e.g. If the insured pays $100, then you'll get a commission whatever you're supposed to get out of $45, NOT $100). Please be aware of this fact, and be away from this company.

Most incompetent insurance company to work with. They will continually find ways to charge you more money. They "audit" your policy after it's two years old and find out how they can charge you half again what you paid for the policy.

I had PIE for a few years. The initial premium was good. Then the audits started happening. I should have just stayed with The Hartford.

Great customer service help me with all my issues and questions

Thank you Ashley

Dealing with Pie is difficult because very little human interaction. No one to call to help with problems. I wanted a live agent. This is the main reason i went with another company. Also, the premium got way too expensive.

Pie Insurance made my immediate need for workers comp insurance a breeze. My agent Samantha was very thorough in her explanation of how things worked from start to finish and had everything completed in less than 24 hours. Pie insurance was a gem of a find and I hope to do business with them for many years to come.

Only thieves, nothing else. It's never possible to receive service, they never respond to their emails. In a word, they are WASTED.They're just trying to steal, they've made up something called an audit

Yes, at the beginning they saved me money, then things turned and a surcharge after the audit, which is a joke.. the the renewal comes thru with a modest increase, and then the second audit that was done by a third party and they were very unresponsive, and the audit results DOUBLED my policy. The renewal for the 3 rd year was another modest increase, but , I declined the renewal and they still took my premium out.. I fought to get it back, which i finally got back. Now , another audit and this audit is the same as my cancelled policy,, I am SO done with this company... I do NOT recommend this company to anyone , including my enemies,

Your salesman made the purchase informative and easy.

I have had this company for 3 years, and got too busy the last 2 years at the end of our policy to change. They are horrible! If you get a human on the phone, they can never help you, and will send you to a vm that will never get responded to. They have left me in the lurch more times than I can count. These positive reviews have got to be from new clients. Our other insurance companies get alot of their unhappy clients. Save yourself future frustration and find a company that actually helps their customers.

I was very impressed! Thank you for giving me hope that there are still people who are helpful and professional!

Was very helpful and professional!
She had a lot of patience with my many questions.
Customer friendly, excellent communication!

Customer service rep was excellent. Answered all my questions and a timely matter. Also I was not put on hold for longer than 10 to 15 seconds. If I can give 10 stars I would. Super Knowledgeable. Provided options on keeping my insurance instead of canceling.

Very knowledgeable and easy to work with. We had a complicated problem and she was very accomodating. Excellent service!

Jazz took her time to listen to my enquiry and patiently sought out for me all the information I needed. I must say it was an amazing, awesome experience. She was professional, patient, empathetic and took it upon herself to see to the quick resolution to my calling.

I used them for WC for my business and after a year, i got a notification that they were dropping me. I was originally recommended by my husband who was also using them for his WC and he also got a letter of notification a few months later that they were also dropping him. A year later they decided to audit me and sent me a bill. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THEM! This is from 2 different companies who used them!

Customer service was amazing! She gave me answers to everything I needed to know and a little extra information that I would need moving forward without an agent.

They offered me a policy of WC and 2 days later they cancelled my policy, because they didn’t offer for clerical employees, although they took my payment of almost $800 and they’re lagging on making me my refund like they promised, if you call and ask for new policy they answer right away, but for this kind of issue I had wait over 1hr and no luck…. Don’t recommend to anyone please stay away

Kelly Rodriguez went above and beyond to assist me with an important matter that was holding up a significant payment from a client. Kelly called & mailed to make sure that we received everything required. We are pleased that our invoice is now being processed.
Thank you Kelly!

On June 10th I began contacting the audit department by email since they do not accept phone calls about audits. I have sent at least 10 unanswered emails. I asked them for an explanation and completed their dispute forms (after weeks went by I had another Workers Comp agent look at my audit). To date I have gotten one response on July 31 asking for more information. I was automatically charged *a lot* after my audit results. I cannot wait to not have this company as my workers comp insurance.