Tuckernuck Reviews 

Obsessed with this dress. Perfect for 4th of July, vacation, and church. I'm planning to wear it to a warm football game and may pair it with a cardigan for fall. It's so comfortable and I love how flattering the waist is. Really hoping they come up with a sleeve option for other seasons.

Unusual fit. I normally a small (wear 4-6) but this is snug through the shoulders yet quite voluminous around the rib cage and on down. Challenging to take up due to the pockets at the waist and no back seam. Due to the shoulders there’s no way I could take an extra small.. sadly, must return. VERY cute dress and high quality. You rarely find anything lined anymore. Wish it would’ve worked out.

Charged $55 CAD to return 1 item, very poor experience and not advised of this at purchase.

I love my new sweatshirt!! It's a nice solution to an itchy wool sweater....for pretty much all day, any day! The comments indicated that it ran small so I ordered a size larger than I would have ordered had I not read the reviews ....and I'm glad I did. Delivery was prompt .... and I love my new shirt!

The shorts were unfortunately too small. I'm closer to a size 16 and the XL was too small. Unfortunately I cannot return them since it is final sale.

I was excited to make my first dress purchase at Tuckernuck! The dress was meant for a boy baby shower garden party theme I’m attending. I verified my measurements with the size chart and ordered the recommended size. Unfortunately the dress is too large and does not match the size chart. Very disappointing.

Very bummed , didn’t fit, bought the white with blue embroidered fish set, bought a small for the top , didn’t know it would be so huge! Didn’t look like the picture, it was a final sale so I’m stuck with it

This dress is even better looking in person…the color combination is gorgeous. The weight of the fabric is going to be perfect for the cool months here in Augusta, Ga.; it is a lovely twill.
Looking forward to accessorizing this Callahan version….hurry Autumn!

Efficient delivery. However product was disappointing.

The size guide is very misleading, making it difficult to order the correct size with confidence. It's also extremely frustrating that final sale items cannot be exchanged. If the sizing is inaccurate, customers are left with an item they can't wear and no option to exchange it, which means losing the money spent. A more accurate size guide and a final sale exchange policy would make for a much better customer experience.

I love love the dress ! It's too large. May I return for the small?

Fast shipping and great clothes.

Unfortunately, it’s my fault. I guess that I didn’t realize there was that much difference between an XX large and an X large so it’s very difficult to tell what’s gonna fit you or not unfortunately I guess that’s the way it is the shirt pinstripe shirt that I bought well I guess I didn’t read it all very good. It’s a half a shirt. I figured it was a button down full light shirt now a half a shirt what could that to me but anyway I’m a little disappointed you know and it almost Makes me feel like I don’t think I’ll be shopping there again. It seems to be no consistency. Thank you Katherine Harrop.

I ordered the Sleeveless Callahan Shirt Dress in Blue Stripe. Small was the indicated size and consistent with other items from Tuckernuck. However, it was too small in the chest. I am not large busted but have I guess athletic shoulders/chest and this dress was just too tight. Also the collar was very stiff and uncomfortable. I really wanted to like it but it wasn't for me so returned rather than exchange size.

However, the return process was very easy - thus the overall 4 star rating.

The dress is gorgeous, but the size does not match up with the size guide at all—it’s 5 inches smaller around the bust than advertised. I’m going to return it.

I tried on this dress and it was exactly what I imagined, great quality. I had to return a similar I ordered from Quince which was poor quality. This one is perfect. Will go with anything nearly anywhere.

Clothes are fantastic! Excellent quality. Unfortunately though - The delivery was like no other I have had. They did try to reach me via text from gate but I was not with my phone. Thankfully I received an image of a package at one of our community gates (we have 2) I picked the front one and crossed my fingers it was still there. No delivery has ever left a package there in 15 years for me and we buy a lot via internet.

Love love love this dress. Perfect fit, love the pockets, the arm elastic is nice and loose. Great deal with 20% off markdowns.

Returned because cut in a lot at the shoulders. Was looking for a sleeveless not an athletic look.