Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. T... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. T... See more
Company replied
Andrew and Lindsay were absolutely fantastic in helping us with our Medicare sign up. They explained everything so we could understand and answered all the questions we had. They were wonderful to w... See more
We are so thankful for the help Andrew and Lindsey gave us. We can't imagine trying to navigate Medicare on our own. They are friendly and knowledgeable and made the process easy. We're confident we g... See more
Company replied
Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help I may need.... See more
Company replied
A veteran owned/operated company, Medicare Management of WNY believes one thing: confidently knowing what to do with Medicare (and when) is THE KEY to avoiding paying late penalties, fees, or fines and since 2015, only our free, 5-star rated and nationally recognized Medicare SmartStart Program™ will show you how. More than 1,150+ WNY'ers widely consider it the most popular and preferred way to get started and signed up for Medicare in Erie County. This program is proven to make your entire process simpler, easier, stress-free and almost effortless. So, if you aren’t sure where to start with Medicare, feeling forced to figure it out alone is no place to be. Let us take away all your stress trying to tackle everything on your own. This proven program includes: (1) In-person strategy session with a Certified Starting Medicare Specialist™ [CSMS], (2) personalized myMedicare SmartPath planning workbook detailing your exact step-by-step timeline and "to-do" list, (3) myMedicare SmartPath Assessment offers accurate answers and advice about your current situation and scenario to directly determine 'IF' you should sign up for Medicare or suspend until later in life, (4) myMedicare SmartPath Audit provides a professional financial analysis between current employer coverage and costs VS Medicare price and out-of-pocket costs, PLUS, in addition to all those really helpful resources, you'll also get (5) private myMedicare SmartID account access to facilitate setting up your single sign-in service with immediate e-application assistance, (6) initial issue of temporary Medicare ID Card, ALONG WITH (7) exclusive use of our Medicare SmartIQ™ Software, which some say is the most sophisticated, specialized software for comparing insurance companies and costs found nowhere else in all of WNY. We will help you to sign up for Medicare Part A + B, sort through the sea of Insurance Companies, and figure out all the fine print of which plan to pick. We have helped residents sign up for Medicare in Erie County, Niagara County, Chautauqua County, Cattaraugus County, Wyoming County, Genesee County, and Orleans County. Our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ can help you avoid IRS tax fines for conflicts with the coordination of coverage between Work Insurance and Medicare, prevent CMS surcharges for incorrect Medicare application paperwork, and even prevent late enrollment penalties for signing up for Medicare after 65. We offer information on: Local, Regional, and National Medicare Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, as well as Medicare Supplement Plans.
8645 Main St, 14221, Buffalo, United States
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. They are very knowledgeable , professional and superior service. Helped us with all our questions and helped us with our choices.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
We are so thankful for the help Andrew and Lindsey gave us. We can't imagine trying to navigate Medicare on our own. They are friendly and knowledgeable and made the process easy. We're confident we got the best plan for our needs.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsay were absolutely fantastic in helping us with our Medicare sign up. They explained everything so we could understand and answered all the questions we had. They were wonderful to work with and would recommend them to everyone we know who needs this service.
I was referred to Andrew & Lyndsey Hibbard several months ago from two friends who just went through the Medicare sign up process. I did not hesitate to give Andrew & Lydsey a call since I had no idea where to start to get signed up and what health carrier to go with. I am so glad that I gave them a call. They made the process very smooth and stress free for me. They have been a great resource for me, and I would highly recommend them to anyone who is approaching the Medicare stage of their life.
Very easy and fast. Andrew and Lyndsey really know what they are doing. Would definitely recommend to anybody getting ready to turn 65 years old .

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lyndsey made the process of signing up for the right coverage for me much easier! They are very knowledgeable and guided me effortlessly through to my choice. I would and do Highly recommend them!

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I was really confused & did not understand about the whole Medicare process. Andrew & Lyndsey explained everything in a way that was easy to understand. Why do it alone when you have an experienced, knowable person like Andrew to help you. I have told my friends who will be turning 65 soon to make an appointment. They won't regret it.
Andrew & Lyndsey were extremely knowledgeable and helpful in guiding me to sign up with Medicare. It was a pleasure to work with them and receive their services. I will highly recommend them to potential future WNY Medicare members.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
we appreciated the prompt and courteous service that we were given. They are very knowledgeable and professional in their field. We would highly recommend this team to anyone seeking guidance in this somewhat overwhelming task of Medicare insurance.
Steve & Jane Karl

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Advertisement mailings make it so confusing, Andrew and Lindsey made it so simple. I was so stressed and they took the stress out. Thank you for taking the stress out. 5 out of 5 stars for me

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
There is NO reason to go it alone, when trying to decide on a Medicare policy. Andrew and Lyndsey are well versed on what is available to you. They then collect the necessary info on your needs, and then help you pick the right policy for you. It does not NOT stop here! I have only been with them a short time, but I have received at least a half dozen mailings keeping me informed of future changes. I couldn't be happier with my choice. Kurt

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
This dynamic duo have been a LIFESAVER to my Medicare application process! Lyndsey's patience as I kept returning to West Seneca 3x's & then the Buffalo office to give additional required information was PHENOMENAL!
I am searching my email for folks I can refer

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I too received dozens of "free meal" invitations to learn about Medicare. They sounded more like a money grab for them. Nothing is ever free. I have family members who used Andrew & Lindsy's services. I was impressed with the no pressure approach. On top of that, they did all the work to secure me a medicare package that I was happy with. I will recommend them to anyone I know that is coming up the age of 65.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
As my wife and I were approaching 65 years of age we were getting bombarded with Medicare literature through the mail. Everything was difficult to understand and very confusing.
Andrew and Lyndsey simplified everything . They compared and explained policies to us and set us up in a plan that took care of all our needs and concerns, saving us money also.
We walked out of their office completely comfortable and confident in our Medicare coverage.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
They were very professional, pleasant and the process was quick and stress-free.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Lyndsey & Andrew were extremely helpful in guiding & helping with decision making. Couldn’t have navigated the process without them. Highly recommend working with them for all your Medicare needs & questions.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I went in with no idea where to even begin, and Andrew and Lyndsey were wonderful! They take you through the process step by step, explaining and answering your questions for a pretty much seamless experience! Highly recommend their services!!

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsey were absolutely amazing.They made my Medicare signup experience fast and easy. Lindsey is so good at getting back to you when you have any questions. I definitely would recommend Andrew and Lindsey with your Medicare management.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsey made a complicated process very stress free and explained everything in language that was easy to understand. Will strongly recommend the to friends and co-workers.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.