Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. T... See more
Company replied
While we don't verify specific claims because reviewers' opinions are their own, we may label reviews as "Verified" when we can confirm a business interaction took place. Read more
To protect platform integrity, every review on our platform—verified or not—is screened by our 24/7 automated software. This technology is designed to identify and remove content that breaches our guidelines, including reviews that are not based on a genuine experience. We recognise we may not catch everything, and you can flag anything you think we may have missed. Read more
Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help we may need. T... See more
Company replied
Andrew and Lindsay were absolutely fantastic in helping us with our Medicare sign up. They explained everything so we could understand and answered all the questions we had. They were wonderful to w... See more
We are so thankful for the help Andrew and Lindsey gave us. We can't imagine trying to navigate Medicare on our own. They are friendly and knowledgeable and made the process easy. We're confident we g... See more
Company replied
Andrew and Lyndsey are simply the best possible choice you can make when making your Medicare decisions. It gives me peace of mind knowing they are available all year round for any help I may need.... See more
Company replied
A veteran owned/operated company, Medicare Management of WNY believes one thing: confidently knowing what to do with Medicare (and when) is THE KEY to avoiding paying late penalties, fees, or fines and since 2015, only our free, 5-star rated and nationally recognized Medicare SmartStart Program™ will show you how. More than 1,150+ WNY'ers widely consider it the most popular and preferred way to get started and signed up for Medicare in Erie County. This program is proven to make your entire process simpler, easier, stress-free and almost effortless. So, if you aren’t sure where to start with Medicare, feeling forced to figure it out alone is no place to be. Let us take away all your stress trying to tackle everything on your own. This proven program includes: (1) In-person strategy session with a Certified Starting Medicare Specialist™ [CSMS], (2) personalized myMedicare SmartPath planning workbook detailing your exact step-by-step timeline and "to-do" list, (3) myMedicare SmartPath Assessment offers accurate answers and advice about your current situation and scenario to directly determine 'IF' you should sign up for Medicare or suspend until later in life, (4) myMedicare SmartPath Audit provides a professional financial analysis between current employer coverage and costs VS Medicare price and out-of-pocket costs, PLUS, in addition to all those really helpful resources, you'll also get (5) private myMedicare SmartID account access to facilitate setting up your single sign-in service with immediate e-application assistance, (6) initial issue of temporary Medicare ID Card, ALONG WITH (7) exclusive use of our Medicare SmartIQ™ Software, which some say is the most sophisticated, specialized software for comparing insurance companies and costs found nowhere else in all of WNY. We will help you to sign up for Medicare Part A + B, sort through the sea of Insurance Companies, and figure out all the fine print of which plan to pick. We have helped residents sign up for Medicare in Erie County, Niagara County, Chautauqua County, Cattaraugus County, Wyoming County, Genesee County, and Orleans County. Our free Medicare SmartStart Program™ can help you avoid IRS tax fines for conflicts with the coordination of coverage between Work Insurance and Medicare, prevent CMS surcharges for incorrect Medicare application paperwork, and even prevent late enrollment penalties for signing up for Medicare after 65. We offer information on: Local, Regional, and National Medicare Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, as well as Medicare Supplement Plans.
8645 Main St, 14221, Buffalo, United States
No recent history of asking for reviews
This company hasn't invited customers recently, so reviews may not be representative
How this company uses Trustpilot
See how their reviews and ratings are sourced, scored, and moderated.
Andrew and Lindsey are a professional team that I feel confident with the decisions I made. They helped me to make decisions that I could not have made without their expertise.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Thank you Lyndsey for once again guiding us through the process of finding the right plan to suit our needs and saving money. I would highly recommend Medicare Management to everyone needing Medicare as Lyndsey and Andrew are very knowledgeable, professional and down to earth people that really "know their stuff".

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
We have had Andrew and Lyndsey helping us with our decision for our health care planning for over 10 years now. They are the best! Helped us with questions and concerns always. Very knowledgeable and we have trusted their help completely! Will continue to recommend them to everyone we know who needs help with their Medicare plan decisions!

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lyndsey were ready to go when
We arrived for our appointment. They make us at ease right away. They also know their stuff. Thanks to both of them for making enrolling in medicare a breeze.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I recently met with Andrew for a Medicare SmartStart Sign Up Session. I appreciate the time he took to explain the sign up process and what I need to do before signing up for Medicare. With Andrew’s expertise, I’m relieved to know it will not be complicated. I’m looking forward to our next meeting and starting a relationship with Medicare Management.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
The background knowledge that Andrew and Lindsay possess is amazing. They were able to explain the Medicare Program, how it works and how to choose the best healthcare plan to fit my needs. I will recommend them to my friends and family.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Very knowledgeable , dealt with my specific needs. Broke things down to dollars and cents to help explain the differences in plans. Independent, not beholden to any specific company. Glad I went.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Medicare Management of WNY is indeed a true expert Medicare help. My wife and I utterly enjoyed the most professional interaction and skilled guidance. This was one of the utmost efficient health insurance experiences that my family encountered in a very long time. Thank you, Medicare Management, of WNY and keep up your fantastic level of performance.
Dr. Vojislav and Biljana Kalanovic

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Probably the best experience I’ve ever had dealing with healthcare. Andrew made it extremely easy to understand, along with handling the applications for me. Extremely happy with the fact that there was no BS involved. He got right straight to the information I needed to have and took care of things extremely quickly. The attention to detail is top-notch. Highly recommend using his company !!!

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Today was my second meeting with Andrew and Lyndsay and I couldn't be happier. They are both very knowledgeable about Medicare and answered all my questions. I would highly recommend them to everyone turning 65.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Lindsey and Andrew clearly know what they are doing. Any question I managed to generate , they immediately had an answer to. Entering into retirement is unnerving and having someone who knows what they are doing takes a lot of the stress away. I'm very thankful I have their help through this process.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsey are the nicest people you too meet. Very knowledgeable in the Medicare field. Answered all my questions and made my decisions that much easier. I highly recommend them to anyone that needs some direction to Medicare decisions. Great job too both 👏

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew & Lyndsey Hibbard are professional, honest, informative and they answered all my questions. When the world finds out you're turning 65, you become inundated with solicitations. The Hibbards know what they're doing, give them a call.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I am so glad that my friend referred me to see Andrew and Lindsey at Medicare Management! They are so helpful and knowledgeable. They answered all of my questions and made me feel more comfortable regarding the medicare process.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
My year of anxiety over choosing medicare was unnecessary once I met Andrew and Lindsey.
I'm retiring from a job I know well, it was a pleasure to turn my needs and concerns over to the hands of people who do their job well.
Not only are professional they are knowledgeable, and very down to earth people. I provided my medical information and they did all the rest.
Questions I had were cut by 80% because they were so thorough to begin with.
No stress what so ever. I’m so happy that I was recommended to them.
There's one location, easily accessible, if you don't live nearby, it's worth the drive.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and lyndsey work seamlessly to insure you have EXACTLY what you need . I HIGHLY recommend them to anyone.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
What a team. They really help me pick the right plan for my situation. My main concern was with prescription drugs and finding the best solution. Every question I had was answered and answered with respect. They really know what they are doing. What a great job they did for me. Thank you

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
I highly recommend Andrew and Lyndsey to make your change over to Medicare. They are professional, knowledgeable, and very down to earth people. You give them your information and they do all the rest. No stress what so ever. I’m so happy that I was recommended to them.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsey are so knowing about Medicare and all the programs that complement Medicare they can find the right coverage to suit your needs and save you money.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Andrew and Lindsey were great at getting us on the right track for Medicare. They answered all are questions and more. They are very quick to call you back when you have a question. I would definitely recommend them to anyone starting their Medicare adventure.

Reply from Medicare Management of WNY
Anyone can write a Trustpilot review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they’ll be displayed as long as an account is active.
We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. Find out how we combat fake reviews.
Learn about Trustpilot’s review process.
Here are 8 tips for writing great reviews.
Verification can help ensure real people are writing the reviews you read on Trustpilot.
Offering incentives for reviews or asking for them selectively can bias the TrustScore, which goes against our guidelines.